Updated through 2013 Winter State Tournaments.
| Total |
School |
| 113 |
Carmel |
| 58 |
North Central (Indianapolis) |
| 34 |
Columbus North (Columbus) |
| 28 |
Bloomington South (Bloomington) |
| 26 |
Anderson |
| 26 |
Ben Davis |
| 26 |
Indianapolis Cathedral |
| 25 |
Gary Roosevelt |
| 23 |
Muncie Burris |
| 22 |
Valparaiso |
| 21 |
Warren Central |
| 20 |
Fort Wayne Bishop Luers |
| 20 |
Martinsville |
| 19 |
Kokomo |
| 17 |
Evansville Mater Dei |
| 17 |
Hammond |
| 17 |
Lafayette Central Catholic |
| 17 |
Muncie Central |
| 16 |
Evansville Memorial |
| 16 |
Park Tudor |
| 16 |
Penn |
| 15 |
Brebeuf Jesuit |
| 15 |
Fort Wayne Northrop |
| 15 |
Indianapolis Bishop Chatard |
| 14 |
Gary Froebel |
| 14 |
Lafayette Jefferson |
| 14 |
Lawrence North |
| 14 |
Roncalli |
| 14 |
South Bend Central (South Bend) |
| 12 |
LaPorte |
| 11 |
Center Grove |
| 11 |
Fort Wayne Bishop Dwenger |
| 11 |
Indianapolis Shortridge |
| 11 |
Munster |
| 10 |
Fort Wayne Canterbury |
| 10 |
Marion |
| 10 |
South Bend Riley |
| 10 |
Southport |